Gil A., Jacksonville, Fla.

We don’t have any argument with switching to a Civic Si from a Corolla S based on performance. The Civic Si is the better choice for acceleration, handling and braking, though it gets lower fuel economy (25 mpg combined versus 30 mpg) and requires premium gas.


We endorse this move even though Honda softened the suspension on the 2012 model compared with previous Civic Si models, sacrificing some handling prowess. Even so, the Civic Si has greater street cred than the Corolla S, which is mechanically identical to the reliable but dull Corolla LE. In contrast, the Civic Si adds a larger, stronger engine, performance tires, larger brakes and sharper steering compared with other Civic models.

We can’t help but wonder, though, how much is this going to cost? If you’re trading in a 2012 Corolla, you will probably get dinged for a full year of depreciation even if you’ve owned it for six months or less. That will cost at least a few thousand dollars, maybe more, plus you’ll have to cough up more for the Civic Si and pay extra at the pump.

If money isn’t an issue, then put the pedal to the metal. If this amounts to more than pocket change for you, then you should ask yourself if the benefits justify the cost.

Learn more

Answered by Rick Popely on December 20, 2012 in Honda , Honda Civic , Toyota , What Car Should I Buy? | Permalink

Search Results Search Results for


See if your question has already been asked and answered

Thank You!

Your question has been successfully submitted to It will now be reviewed by our editors and we'll answer it soon if we think it's a useful question. You will be notified via e-mail when the answer is posted. tackles your questions about new cars and the car-buying process. Unfortunately we can't answer questions regarding:

  • Used cars.
  • Most aftermarket products.
  • Mechanical issues. You can visit our friends at Car Talk to discuss your mechanical problems.
Thanks for your interest.


Have our experts answer any of your questions about new cars.

Email us at

Maintenance Advice
Get answers from the
Car Talk Community